Pot Roast

I've had a Pot Roast Recipe for years. You can do the same one, it is on the back of the Lipton's Beefy Dry Onion soup. A couple of years ago I decided that I could do better than that, plus my quack, er Doctor, wanted me to reduce salt. The Lipton's package is rather salty.

I've a decent Onion Soup, actually a couple of them. My wife wanted me to go with Julia, but I figured Thomas Keller's Onion Soup from Bouchon was a better bet. Actually we use his sweated onions a lot. Enough that I do 20 lbs at a time and freeze. As a matter of fact I'm down to my last bag, so sweating onions is on the to do list, as is lots of dry cure and some baking. And stock, around this kitchen, is not a problem.

So I like to do this pot roast with a blade chuck steak 2-3 inches thick. Fortunately I had a couple on hand.

My wife was using the big Dutch oven for turkey ragu, the third serial use of the Thanksgiving birds, so I used the cast iron one.



And assembled my mise.





That is about a 3 pound chuck steak.

The only other specific amount is 1.5 cups of the onions from the Thomas Keller Onion soup recipe from Bouchon on pps 47-50.

3 lb Chuck Steak 2 or so inches thick.
1.5 cups sweated onions
root vegetables as desired (onions, carrots,  turnips, parsnips, celeriac, rutabagas, potatoes and I also use celery.
several pieces of pancetta (see here).
dark beef stock, home made or use water.
Red wine (of course drinkable, have a glass while cooking).  Note, if you don't use wine, use more beef stock.
Salt and pepper as needed.
A bay leaf.

You will need an oven thermometer with probe.

Set oven to 275 F.

Put the pancetta (or at least bacon, or if Kosher, schmaltz) in the bottom of the Dutch oven over heat, you are using this instead of adding oil.




After some cooking remove and reserve the pancetta, you will need to cut it into small pieces.

Brown the seasoned chuck.





Insert thermometer probe.

Start adding root vegetables in a size that you like. Celery isn't a root vegetable, but I like it.

There are also two pints of beef stock that had been frozen in there.



Add back in the cut up pancetta.



Add the sweated onions


I will add more vegetables than that, this makes at least 6 servings.

Fill to near top with beef stock and red wine. I use 2 cups stock to 1 cup wine.

Place in oven, watch thermometer and when it gets to 175 F turn oven down to 190F.

I wanted the pot roast to have a couple of hours at about 185 F, range of 180-190. I don't know if I got that idea from Ruhlman or McGee or if I infered something from their writing. About four hours total, longer isn't a problem, WATCH THE TEMPERATURE!

It works, the pot roast



seen above was moist. You can dry out meat being braised by heating above 190 F.



I don't put potatoes in the pot as we prefer this over mashed potatoes, which my wife does with a food mill.

And this was a quite appropriate meal for a day like the one in the picture below.



Which is the view from my home office.




 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments
Page: 1 of 1
  • 12/24/2008 1:08 PM Fitzie wrote:
    Looks delicious. Snow and pot roast do seem to go together! We got a few inches last night. Nothing to brag about but at least we can claim a white Christmas this year.
    Merry Christmas!
    Fitzie
    Reply to this
  • 12/27/2008 12:12 PM Scott Harris wrote:
    Have you ever tried a pressure cooker? We did short ribs (and have done pot roast) that way last week. Less than an hour.
    Reply to this
  • 12/27/2008 1:37 PM ntsc wrote:
    I was explicitly trying to keep the internal temperature between 180-190. I couldn't do that in a pressure cooker.

    Some place I read or infered that that range is the ideal one for cooking this sort of cut of meat.
    Reply to this
  • 12/28/2008 11:15 PM Jesse wrote:
    That food and that view... *envy envy envy*
    Reply to this
  • 12/29/2008 7:45 AM ntsc wrote:
    The food anyone can do with practice.

    The view is Harriman State Park in NY, so it is not likely to ever be developed. It is also watershed, they do allow hiking, but don't allow hunting.

    It is the south end of a 100 square mile park with well over 100 miles of maintained hiking trails, including the Long Path - George Washington Bridge to Albany and points north, and the Appalacan Trail.

    We saw that view and that sold the house.
    Reply to this
  • 1/2/2009 3:56 PM ErikaK wrote:
    Looks delightful as does all the sausage. We had a wet and windy Xmas in the Central Coast of CA. No snow, though we can see it in the mountains above Orange County now. I sometimes miss it from growing up in Colorado..... but not really
    Happy New Year!
    Reply to this
  • 1/3/2009 6:23 AM Attila the Mom wrote:
    If I've ever made a decent pot roast, it was always by accident. LOL

    Thanks for the step-by-step!

    And Happy New Year to you and yours. May you create many wonderful meals in 2009!
    Reply to this
  • 1/6/2009 11:00 AM Donalyn wrote:
    I love seeing all the different ways that folks make a pot roast - this one looks yummy!
    Reply to this
  • 3/9/2009 8:31 PM Bterry wrote:
    Just tried this recipe over the weekend and it was FANTASTIC. Now I know what I have been doing wrong - well, 2 things I have been doing wrong - I have been cooking at at too high a temp which dries out the meat, and using a cut of beef that is frankly too lean. This was perfect.
    Reply to this
  • 3/13/2009 6:01 AM ntsc wrote:
    As I said I got or inferred the temperature range from Rhulman or McGee and dry/not dry was very hit and miss.

    I use the same technique now on most roast meat that I don't want rare to medium rare, don't let the internal temp get above 190. I did this on the stuffed pork chops as well and they too were moist.
    Reply to this
  • 6/29/2010 6:39 AM gratis Bingo wrote:
    I was searching on the web for the same thing, found..but couldn’t figure out how to run..I did have problems with this so plz solve my problem..
    Reply to this

Page: 1 of 1
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.